Written and directed by Cameron Crowe
Starring Tom Cruise, Penélope Cruz, Jason Lee, Cameron Diaz, Kurt Russell, Noah Taylor, Timothy Spall, Tilda Swinton, and Michael Shannon
What a strange movie whose increasingly surreal journey could have devolved into a hollow waste of time, but this rewatch proves that it still has a good grasp on its emotional and psychological meat while offering up a weirdly vulnerable lens into the enigmatic King of Cinema and Scientology mainstay that is Tom Cruise. I prefer this over the 1997 movie that it’s remaking, Open Your Eyes, which I saw last year. But I do want to clarify that I enjoyed Open Your Eyes, and it’s interesting to hold up these two tales in a side-by-side fashion, which helps us realize how Vanilla Sky is pretty damn faithful towards adapting a ton of the material from the OG film. And yet these two stories land as very different things in my head, especially when we’re involving Cruise and reading his version through the lens that maybe, just maybe it’s metatextually engaging with him—this incredibly and conventionally handsome fellow who holds a massive amount of power and privilege in his hands, but as much as audiences may fawn over him, there remains a mysterious air looming over him. He’s perched on his own little platform that stands high over all of us and maintains a vast distance between us and Cruise. He’s off in his own celebrity bubble that ensures we’ll never get to truly know the real him, and this is only getting reinforced by whatever security measures Scientology has put in place to seclude the Core of Cruise away from society. The fact that he’s as widely beloved as he is right now lands as a proper indicator of just how effectively his PR has been handled, and it becomes more glaring when we consider how popular it once was to view him as a plain old weirdo. Jumping back to the Knight & Day/Mission: Impossible – Ghost Protocol/Rock of Ages/Jack Reacher/Oblivion/Edge of Tomorrow period of his career provides a reminder of how his image was on sincerely wobbly footing, and his good looks and intensely friendly charm couldn’t be confidently relied on as tools to help him escape this predicament.
But his reputation has managed to evolve past that. The crowds adore this pillar of Hollywood as he eats up his popcorn and promotes new releases like Sinners, The Running Man, and The Odyssey. It’s all so fascinating to watch, and hey, I can understand why he’s captivated so many people. He does boast that strong of a charisma, and I do genuinely think he’s a skilled actor whose talent expands outside of him being just an action star. Look at what he’s done in projects like Eyes Wide Shut, Interview with the Vampire, Vanilla Sky, Collateral, and Minority Report. These parts have all presented their own challenging aspects that push him off the road of a traditional action lead, and they’re the parts that I’m the most interested in seeing him take on. Magnolia probably counts as well, but I’m only not listing it here because I have yet to watch it. I’m aware of him playing an Andrew Tate-esque motivational speaker there, though, and I’m sure he does a good job at that. In any case, these pieces of his career all came from an earlier time that exists before he had to tighten up his exterior and keep it all polished for the audience’s benefit. These are pieces that give us just a bit more of a glimpse inside of him, and Vanilla Sky is a great example of that with its portrayal of the deeply lonesome, entitled, and vain David Aames. Let me tell you that before we reach the fateful car crash, I’m not as invested in his story as I should be. I’m coasting through it just fine for sure, but there’s a superficiality to his world and the relationships that he has with the people who are “closest” to him, and it’s a superficiality that keeps me somewhat detached from his journey. It leaves me wondering if I’ll be lower on this movie than I’d expected, since I remember liking it when I saw it years ago.
But then the car crash arrives to hurl David down a whole new path, and this is where I’m able to engage with the narrative more thoroughly. The hedonistic breeziness of his playboy life has fractured into a landscape of imperfection—a landscape whose border between what’s real and what’s imagined becomes blurrier and blurrier until it all falls apart into an existential nightmare. What this does under the helm of writer-director Cameron Crowe to explore that substance is a riveting thing to watch in all of its dreaminess and sentimentality. It keeps me in my seat despite there being a part of me that wonders why I should give a crap about a privileged, egotistical, and shallow dickweasel like David. The supporting cast of Penélope Cruz, who’s reprising the role of Sofia from Open Your Eyes and who’s consistently gripping opposite Cruise; Jason Lee, whose laidback buddy energy encourages me to believe that Brian really would hang out with David, even though there are numerous times where I have to question what’s going on precisely with Brian and whether or not he’s a true friend; Cameron Diaz, who brings a sympathetic quality to Julie while she’s become so fixated on David, a guy who should be careful when he’s playing around with her heart; and Kurt Russell, who successfully exudes a likably paternal vibe that’s evocative of how he plays Ego in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2—they’re all excellent as well. Hell, we even get people like Timothy Spall, Michael Shannon, Tilda Swinton, Alicia Witt, Ken Leung, Shalom Harlow, Johnny Galecki, Conan O’Brien, and Steven Spielberg popping in for their own small parts, which is amusing. Then I have to hand out kudos to the cinematography, the lighting, and the editing for their contributions to the atmosphere that can get so gorgeous and so askew at the same time. I can be mesmerized by something like those heavenly skies that could have sprouted straight from a painting, but then I can also take a step back and go, “Hold on, what’s really going on with this plane of existence?” And I’m saying this as someone who already knows what’s happening, but that doesn’t do a lot to significantly diminish the impact that the surrealism is having on me.
Some time ago, I’d decided to rewatch the ending of Vanilla Sky on a whim, and I was startled by how palpably it had struck my heart. Sure, we could read the mawkish nostalgia of the tone through a lens that says it’s a bunch of corny manipulation, but I personally think the movie is being darkly self-aware of how this is operating within the story. I think it knows how saddening these circumstances actually are, and it increases my appreciation for what this is doing. Plus, the usage of “Untitled #4 – Njósnavélin” by Sigur Rós only serves to enhance the emotional potential there. It’s evocative of how another one of their tunes, “Untitled #3 – Samskeyti,” jacks up my devastation at the end of Mysterious Skin. In general, I click with Vanilla Sky’s soundtrack, including the on-point deployment of “Everything In Its Right Place” by Radiohead. And when the credits roll, I’m satisfied with where it’s left us. I’d prefer to love the narrative as a whole more strongly, but so much of the pre-car crash material is still something that I have to work hard at connecting with. Maybe this is a purposeful aspect, but in any case, it pulls me in more deeply after the car accident. I don’t have to worry about the rest of the 136-minute runtime dragging out into an empty tour of this playboy’s self-indulgent life. On a side note, it’s funny to dive back into Vanilla Sky after having just seen what Crowe did with Elizabethtown, which is definitely not on the same quality level here. But I bring this up because it simply highlights how focused Crowe is on rolling out the sentimentality for us viewers, even when it plunges into the most bizarre territory. I’ve seen those two movies and Jerry Maguire as of this writing, so I’m curious to check out more of his oeuvre.
My final rating: 4 out of 5 stars

