Pop-Tart Quest: Chocolate Cupcake

Sometimes an article series disappears for months at a time before making a triumphant, if temporary return! Maybe it’s not the author’s fault! Maybe there hasn’t been anything new to write about! Ever think about that? No, you only think of yourself! I’m so tired of your nagging ALL THE TIME. This is… POP-TART QUEST

Wait, did you forget about Pop-Tart Quest? That is disheartening. Let me (and that link to the previous entries) refresh your memory…

The #PTQ (GET ON TRENDING THAT, FOLKS!) is my quest to try every flavor of Pop-Tarts that I can get my hands on and then review them for you. This is my… 29th article in the series, I believe. And while I may be cramming my gullet full of processed sludge, I do have standards! WHICH ARE:

  1. I have not and will not bother reviewing the flavors EVERYONE knows and has tried. So no basic Strawberry, Cherry, Blueberry, S’Mores, Fudge, etc. This is classy, extravagant shit only here at the #PTQ.
  2. It has to be REAL, ACTUAL Pop-Tarts. I love and respect every single one of you that has sent me pictures of Pop-Tarts cereal or the little Pop-Tarts Bites, but I am only covering the actual toaster pastries at this point. The reason mostly being that those gimmick snacks are always just basic strawberry or fudge but in a new design, and as I noted: I’m not worrying myself with those flavors. It’d be like if I were reviewing every flavor of Pepsi and someone suggested Pepsi flavored jelly beans. I appreciate the heart you show… but it’s just outside the bounds of the spirit of it all!
Image result for chocolate cupcake pop tarts

Hello flavor my new friend. I’ve come to snack on you again. Inside a shell of chocolate so flaky, there is a cream awakening. And it reminds me that the Pop-Tart Quest still remains. It’s the taste… of cupcakes.

(I totally didn’t have to YouTube a video of that song to remember how it went or anything. NO, YOU’RE A LIAR!)

I actually only know two things about The Sound of Silence. One is that the Beastie Boys have a song called The Sounds of Science, and it is better. Two is that they used it in the Netflix revival of Arrested Development, and it was one of the few plusses to that series.


These are good. Visually they desperately want you to recall Hostess Cupcakes, and honestly–maybe it’s a mental placebo thing?–they kind of taste like them, too. The shell is more crumbly like a cupcake that the typical Pop-Tart shell, so that helps. And I love cream over the usual Pop-Tart sludge, so it all adds up to a pleasant experience.

Would I eat them over the ACTUAL cupcake they are impersonating?

Hm, no. I wouldn’t. The cream in those is just better. Lighter and less congealed. But these are a fine substitute. I’m not besmirching them, but as it is with Pop-Tarts, what they are trying to be so often falls short of the original article.

BUT if you ate cupcakes for breakfast, people give you the old side-eye! No one thinks twice about these.

You know… almost thirty Tarts in, and I wonder… does anyone eat Pop-Tarts for NOT breakfast? I, personally, find it abhorrent. I literally can ONLY eat them for breakfast. A Pop-Tart at 3:00pm? I THINK NOT, SIRRAH.

TASTE: A- : These are pretty good, but there’s something slightly… bitter or off with them? It passes. They are nice.

SHELL: B+ : Flaky, crumbles shell! So much better than stale pastry shell.

HO-HO’s: The single best Hostess treat. Better than these cupcakes. OH! I want Ho-Ho’s Pop-Tarts. But they’d just… be these, right? OH MY GOD IF THEY MADE DIFFERENT FLAVORS OF HO-HO’S? Ho-Ho Quest!

TOASTED-TO-UNTOASTED RATIO: 55% : Not as high as you’d think. Toasting these added to the “slightly off” taste I mentioned. But the cream really asks for it. It’s dealer’s choice.


These are the bottom-end of the top-tiers of Pop-Tarts. It might be a bit worse than Confetti Cupcake somehow, but… it’s close.

One thought on “Pop-Tart Quest: Chocolate Cupcake

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s